Old Fashioned Recipes From Scratch – This classic recipe is easy to make with bourbon, bitters, orange peel and your choice of sweetener.
This simple whiskey cocktail is a perennial favorite. Made simply with your choice of whiskey, bitters, sweetener, and orange peel, this drink is easy to make in just a few minutes. It’s also one of those satisfying, classy cocktails that never goes out of style.
Old Fashioned Recipes From Scratch
I like to add an orange twist, a chunky ice cube, and a Luxardo cherry to my old recipe. But you are welcome, of course, to decorate and serve yours as you wish. I’ve included a variety of options below for the different types of whiskey and sweetener you can use. But I have to say that the classic bourbon and sugar cube combo will never let you down.
Old Fashioned Georgia Pecan Log
Before we get to the full recipe below, here are some notes about the basic ingredients you’ll need to make this cocktail:
When did the old cocktail begin? The historical origin of this cocktail is certainly murky, but it probably started in the middle of the 19th century. Here’s a good article about “confused” ancient history if you want to read more.
What is the best bourbon for old cocktails? Ideally you want a high proof bourbon with bold flavor notes, so that the flavor of the bourbon is not overpowered by the citrus and bitters. Bulleit, Four Roses Single Barrel, Woodford Reserve, Buffalo Trace are widely available bourbons that I always enjoy in this cocktail.
Seriously Good Old Fashioned
Need some old snow? You really need ice to mix and cool the cocktail. But you are welcome to defrost before serving if you like. Man, if there’s anything to celebrate in 2020, it’s over. And what better way to celebrate than with a good cocktail?
We love to dive in and test each ingredient in a classic Old Fashioned to truly create that perfect cocktail bar drink. Good news: We think we’ve done it.
In simple terms, an Old Fashioned is a cocktail made with bourbon, sugar, bitters, orange, and cherry. But depending on the quality and quantity of the ingredients, you can get a wide range of flavors. So we did a lot of testing to make sure we perfected the recipe.
Essential Whiskey Cocktail: Old Fashioned
The first question we tried to answer is what kind of sugar tastes best in an Old Fashioned. The second question is whether simple syrup or sugar cube is better. Therefore, we tested the following sugar in our cocktail:
It was very difficult to get any of the sugar cubes to dissolve completely. We try to combine them, add them to another bourbon, and anything else we can think of. The best trick we have and it works in a pinch is to dissolve a sugar cube in hot water first. It’s like a quick and easy simple syrup. It’s not perfect, but it works if that’s all you have or you don’t want to make simple syrup.
In our testing, turbinado simple syrup makes the best Old Fashioned. We tested turbinado sugar, organic cane sugar, and regular cane syrup together in the same cocktail. Although either works, the turbinado makes for a sophisticated Old Fashioned and it turns out to be the clear winner.
Banana Pudding Recipe From Scratch
Organic sugar cane is a good alternative, but regular sugar cane often lacks a deep flavor and is our last choice.
Other sweeteners are fine, and agave is the best. We tried agave, maple syrup, and honey right after each other in the same cocktails. Honey is almost indigestible. Maple syrup leaves a nasty, maple-y aftertaste. Agave digests the best and is a much better alternative to sugar.
How much simple syrup should I put in my Old Fashioned? We found the sweet spot to be 2 tablespoons (or 2 bar spoons). Many recipes call for a spoon, or you may choose a sweet drink, but we find 2 teaspoons perfectly balance the cocktail.
Old Fashioned Chicken Soup From Scratch (using A Whole Chicken)
We try as many bourbons as we can find that are available to as many people as possible. The bourbon you use will probably have a big impact on the flavor of the drink. Using local or small batch bourbon can also be a nice twist on this classic drink if you can find it.
These bourbons make acceptable cocktails, but they don’t have the same quality results as we’ve seen in other cocktails:
This is a fun experiment because many recipes only call for adding a marschino cherry or cocktail cherry. How much of a difference would it make?
Grandma’s Old Fashioned Apple Pie
It turns out, a big difference. If the cherry is the “icing on the cake” of the cocktail, then you want to prepare it.
The main difference in cocktail cherry is the size of the syrup. It’s very interesting to know that some cherries drip into a molasses-like syrup while others are in a very light syrup near light maple syrup.
Maraschino cherries are fine if that’s your only option, but not desirable. Since this recipe takes a cocktail from “decent” to “I’d happily pay that at a cocktail bar,” it’s one of those details that’s easy to overlook but can be a game changer. Having a nice jar of cherries enhances the drink.
Old Fashioned Recipe
Our favorite “thick syrup” cherry is Maraska. Maraska, Luxardo, and Fabbri are all decent and fun cherries, but we’d go for Maraska if you can find it.
Our favorite “simple syrup” cherry is the Woodford Reserve cherry. However, Jack Rudy is almost as sweet.
We’ve seen many restaurants and recipes that call for different ways to add orange to a cocktail. This includes:
How To Make An Old Fashioned In Two Minutes
An orange peel sprinkled over the drink is a perfect match. While dipping a slice of orange is a fun addition, it’s very easy to overdo the drink and ruin the overall flavor.
A sprinkling of orange peel gives the right citrus zest but doesn’t destroy the deep flavor of the drink.
Ice serves a basic purpose – a way to make a cold drink. But it also has the ability to elevate a drink to bar-style quality. You have several options for your ice cream, but we have an Old Fashioned favorite. Here’s what we tried:
Shochu Cocktail Recipe: Shiitake Old Fashioned
A quick note on the clear ice cubes. It will melt a little and your drink will be cold. Making clear ice cubes is not as easy as it sounds. Some of this comes from the purity of the water, but the real trick to making clear ice at home is slowly cooling the water.
We tried several manufacturers to make it at home and our favorite is the True Cubes ice mold.
There are some amazing craft bitters available, and we encourage you to give them a try if you find something you like.
Mezcal Old Fashioned (oaxaca Old Fashioned) — Zestful Kitchen
We tried local craft bitters and they were fun, but our best results were using a combination of the above.
Our favorite combination is 3 dashes Angostura and 3 dashes orange bitters. Old Fashioned Brothers Money Bitters will work but be delicious if you use our recommended simple syrup recipe.
If you try this recipe, let us know! Leave a comment, rate it, and don’t forget to #tag the photo on Instagram. Hello, friends!
Old Fashioned Cocktail The Little Epicurean
The perfect recipe for how to make a quality Old Fashioned cocktail at home, every time. Only 6 ingredients and an easy recipe are needed.
*To make a simple syrup, add 1 part sugar (we like turbinado more complex) and 1 part water to a small saucepan and heat over medium heat, stirring constantly until the sugar dissolves. Cool, pour into a jar or squeeze bottle, and use as directed. Store leftovers in the refrigerator for up to 1 month. *Use organic turbinado sugar to make homemade simple syrup if you want to make sure the recipe is vegan friendly.
Serving: One cocktail Calories: 172 Carbohydrates: 8.4 g Protein: 0 g Fat: 0 g Saturated Fat: 0 g Polyunsaturated Fat: 0 g Monounsaturated Fat: 0 g Trans Fat: 0 g I -Cholesterol: 0 mg Sodium: 1 mg Potassium: mg Fiber: 0.1 g Sugar: 8.3 g Vitamin A: 1.94 IU Vitamin C: 27.72 mg Calcium: 2.32 mg Iron: 0.04 mg If this cocktail doesn’t fill you with Holiday Cheer I don’t know what it will say. It is inspiring and full of seasonal spices.
Two Classic Old Fashioned Bourbon Whiskey Recipes
I, personally, am not a huge fan of bourbon. I really wanted it, because I find it very nice to order bourbon and whiskey in the dark corners of the hotel – but somehow it’s too much. My husband, on the other hand, is a huge bourbon/whiskey fan and always orders an Old Fashioned.
A few months ago we were at an Indian restaurant that served an Indian Style Old Fashioned – and to make a long story short: I had a blast. Unbelievably delicious!
So I decided to see if I could recreate them at home for Thanksgiving. My results were a little different, but just as good.
The Classic Old Fashioned Cocktail
But this Spiced Old Fashioned isn’t just for Thanksgiving, it’s a true Holiday Cocktail.
Old fashioned brownies from scratch, old fashioned sugar cookie recipes from scratch, old fashioned biscuits from scratch, old fashioned cake recipes from scratch, old fashioned caramel cake recipes from scratch, old fashioned dumplings from scratch, old fashioned pancakes from scratch, old fashioned butter cookies recipes from scratch, old fashioned strawberry shortcake recipes from scratch, old fashioned cakes from scratch, old fashioned pound cake recipes from scratch, old fashioned bread pudding recipes from scratch